Psychological Impact of Being in an On-and-Off Relationship

May 17 2025 TalktoAngel 0 comments 592 Views

Relationships are intended to provide support, stability, and opportunities for emotional development. But what happens when a relationship becomes a constant cycle of breaking up and getting back together? While it might feel like the connection is too strong to let go, being in an on-and-off relationship can do more damage than good, especially when it crosses into the realm of toxic relationships, emotional manipulation, and unresolved issues like cheating & infidelity.

At first, the reunions might feel like rekindled love. But over time, the repeated cycle of conflict, separation, and reunion can lead to long-term emotional consequences. In this blog, we’ll explore how these relationships impact mental health and why it’s so important to recognise the signs before it takes a deeper toll.

1. The Stress and Anxiety of Uncertainty

One of the most common effects of an on-again, off-again relationship is chronic stress and anxiety. Never knowing where you stand in a relationship creates a constant state of emotional tension. Questions like “Will we break up again next week?” start to dominate your thoughts.

This ongoing emotional instability can lead to overthinking, fear of abandonment, and even physical symptoms such as insomnia, headaches, or loss of appetite. Over time, your nervous system becomes overstimulated, leaving you emotionally exhausted and always on edge.

2. Emotional Abuse in Disguise

While not all on-and-off relationships are abusive, some can involve subtle forms of emotional abuse. Continually splitting up and getting back together might be a control mechanism. One partner may use threats of leaving or guilt-tripping as a tactic to manipulate the other into compliance or silence.

Over time, this can deeply damage self-esteem and distort your perception of what a healthy relationship looks like. You might start believing that love is supposed to hurt or that emotional chaos equals passion. In reality, it’s just conditioning you to accept instability as normal.

3. Depression and Emotional Burnout

The emotional highs and lows of this kind of relationship can lead to symptoms of depression. Each breakup feels like a loss, even if it’s temporary. And each reunion can feel like false hope, especially if the same problems resurface.

You may begin to lose interest in other parts of life—work, hobbies, friendships—because so much of your energy is invested in the emotional rollercoaster. Feelings of hopelessness, sadness, and lack of motivation become common. Over time, this cycle can lead to full-blown emotional burnout.

4. Trust Issues: Cheating and Infidelity

In many on-and-off relationships, unresolved issues like cheating & infidelity are major triggers for breakups. While some couples believe they can overcome betrayal, constantly returning to a partner who has broken their trust can worsen psychological wounds.

Rebuilding trust requires time, effort, and consistent behaviour. But when the relationship is constantly ending and restarting, that trust never fully heals. Instead, it creates an undercurrent of suspicion and paranoia that slowly eats away at the connection.

Even worse, repeated infidelity or vague boundaries during “off” periods can create emotional confusion. You might ask yourself: Was it cheating if we weren’t technically together? These blurred lines make it harder to move forward and only add to the emotional chaos.

5. Breaking Up Doesn’t Always Mean Healing

In a traditional breakup, there’s space for healing, growth, and closure. But when you’re stuck in a loop, those opportunities are constantly interrupted. Just as you begin to move on, they text you again. Or maybe you reach out, craving comfort in a moment of weakness. And just like that, the cycle resets.

You never get the chance to fully process the breakup or reflect on what went wrong. The emotional confusion can also leave you stuck in the past, unable to create space for new, healthier relationships.

6. The Illusion of “True Love”

On-and-off relationships can create the illusion that what you’re experiencing is a passionate, unbreakable bond. Not necessarily.

Often, the real reason you’re returning is because of emotional dependency, loneliness, or unresolved trauma, not genuine compatibility. This emotional attachment can trick your brain into thinking you’re in love when in reality, you're just addicted to the cycle.

Much like addiction, the relationship offers temporary highs followed by painful lows. The familiarity of the pattern becomes comforting, even when it's damaging.

7. Emotional Instability and Anxiety

One of the most immediate effects of an on-and-off relationship is emotional instability. The constant uncertainty about whether you're together or not, whether it will work this time or end again, can trigger persistent anxiety. You may find yourself overanalyzing texts, second-guessing conversations, or constantly worrying about doing something that could lead to another breakup.

This instability can activate a heightened state of stress in the brain, similar to what happens in situations of chronic uncertainty. You’re essentially living in a relationship “limbo,” and over time, this can create or exacerbate issues like generalised anxiety, sleep problems, or panic attacks.

8. Lowered Self-Esteem

Every time a relationship ends, it delivers a psychological blow, no matter how mutual or amicable it may seem. In an on-again, off-again dynamic, these repeated breakups can deeply affect your sense of self-worth. Over time, the relationship may become a source of shame rather than support, eating away at your confidence and self-image.

Recognising When It’s Toxic

Not every on-and-off connection is poisonous, but many are. Here are a few red flags:

Repeated emotional abuse or manipulation
A cycle of cheating or broken promises
Feeling drained, anxious, or depressed more often than feeling happy
Loss of self-identity or confidence
Inability to trust or feel secure

If these patterns sound familiar, it’s time to ask yourself: Is this relationship helping me grow? Or is it holding me back?

Conclusion

Love isn’t supposed to feel like constant survival. Breaking out of an on-again, off-again relationship can be incredibly difficult, especially if you've built emotional dependency. But with support from friends, therapy, or even just honest self-reflection, you can break the cycle.

Letting go doesn't mean you failed. It means you're brave enough to choose yourself over the pain of staying stuck.

Contributed By: Contributed by Dr. (Prof.) R. K. Suri, Clinical Psychologist and Life Coach, &. Ms. Sheetal Chauhan, Counselling Psychologist.

Reference